Panel Agrees That Southern Miss Logo Too Similar To Iowa’s
USM’s trademark application was denied last week by judges in the United States Patent and Trademark Office, who ruled 2-1 in favor of Iowa.
The ruling has left USM’s attorneys scouring the 54-page decision.“Our attorneys are reviewing the decision by the judges,” USM athletic director Richard Giannini said Tuesday. “Until we have their review, we’re not really going to comment on it.”
Jason Bush, an attorney with Baker Donelson in Jackson, said USM could appeal the decision, which was made by the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, to the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington, D.C.
“In the alternative,” wrote Bush in an email, “USM has the option of presenting additional evidence or raising additional claims in the United States District Court in any district venue that is proper.”
Giannini and other USM officials have long argued that the logos bare little resemblance.
USM unveiled its new Golden Eagle logo in January 2003 in an overhaul of the athletic department’s brand – and it quickly became part of the school’s athletic identity.
The eagle head logo is painted on the artificial turf at M.M. Roberts Stadium and on the basketball court at Reed Green Coliseum.
It’s on the pants worn by USM football players and on USM shirts, hats, jackets, pants and other items sold throughout the state.
The logo was created by USM graduate Rodney Richardson, who owns RARE Design, a graphic design firm based in Hattiesburg.
In 2004, Iowa officials argued that the two images were confusingly similar.
Last week, Iowa got two out of three judges to concur.
“Specifically, (USM) argues that each of the Iowa Hawkeyes marks is a collection of four separate silhouette shapes put together in close proximity creating a two dimensional image that is then displayed against backgrounds of changing colors. (USM) suggests that each Iowa Hawkeyes mark has the simplicity of a stenciled or stamped image. By contrast, Southern Miss argues that its new eagle head is more complex, having the “fierce eyed gaze of independence” and the “black peak of the beak” to create a “symbol of courage and power, reminiscent of Roman soldiers … going into battle [with] a crimson banner with a golden eagle emblazoned on the banner.”
Bucher wrote that he found fault in USM’s argument:
“The overall similarity in appearance of the marks on the goods, particularly in light of the use of identical color schemes, creates virtually identical commercial impressions.”
USM made the case that the use of birds of prey as mascots is prevalent in college sports along with the use of bird heads as logos. USM submitted several examples to back its claim.
Bucher also shot down that argument: “When making a visual comparison between Iowa’s Hawkeyes marks and each of these designs, we find that none of these Division I third-party marks remotely resembles Iowa’s Hawkeyes designs.
Certainly, none is as similar to Iowa’s marks as is (USM’s) mark. Moreover, whether some of these third-party marks (e.g., those having commercial impressions quite distinct from the marks of Iowa and USM) are similar to each other is not relevant to our analysis, and has no bearing on the question of whether the marks in this case are likely to cause confusion.”
In his conclusion, Bucher wrote that he sided with Iowa out of caution and precedent.
The lone dissenter on the board was administrative trademark judge Tom Wellington, who largely supported USM’s case in a brief dissenting opinion.
He wrote that he does not believe there is a likelihood of confusion and that “the parties’ marks may be distinguished as two visually different bird head logos being used in connection with two different sports teams, albeit on the same goods.”
You Might Also Like
Latest News
Merrimack removes lacrosse player for racist remark
Merrimack College announced the removal of one of its men’s lacrosse playe... Read more »Study: Sports play critical role in promoting girls’ mental health
As the nation continues to grapple with a youth mental health crisis, the Women�... Read more »Popular Now
- Minnesota boys basketball team refused to play… March 25, 2024
- 10 must-read books for coaches & athletic directors December 21, 2023
- Study: Parents’ sideline behavior greatly… April 16, 2024
- OSAA defends gender policy regarding trans student-athletes April 23, 2024
- Merrimack removes lacrosse player for racist remark April 25, 2024
Videos
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=93bSs23T9Pw&ab_channel=GAMSSports TeamSnap's Website Builder is the easiest and fastest way to create a professional website. All of the sites are mobile responsive and sync with TeamSnap data, allowing your members to register and view their schedule from one location. Click here to learn more about their special offer to start your year off with a ... continue »
https://youtu.be/Dx7vRdT7e54 Feltrim Sports offers state-of-the-art facilities for football, soccer, lacrosse, and non-traditional sports - conveniently located within Balmoral Resort Florida, a luxury vacation home resort perfect for the whole family. To learn more, visit www.feltrimsports.com. {Sponsored}... continue »
FHSAA considers adding esports to athletic offerings
The FHSAA is considering adding esports to its athletic offerings afte...