Brawl Could Have Major Implications On W.Va. H.S. Football Playoffs

November 23, 2010 / Football
Charleston Daily Mail (W.Va.)

CHARLESTON, W.Va. — Today could have more influence on the end result of the 2010 Class AAA state football playoffs than any day before or after.

The Secondary School Activities Commission is expected to announce today the final results of its investigation into a brawl that broke out near the end of Friday night’s playoff quarterfinal between South Charleston and Hurricane at University of Charleston Stadium.

South Charleston won the game, 30-26.

“We’re relying on the official reports, and we’re waiting on those to be completed,” SSAC Executive Secretary Gary Ray said Sunday. “We’ll talk to South Charleston, then talk to Hurricane (today) since their season is over.”

An officiating crew from the Class A Mason-Dixon Conference (whose members include Bishop Donahue, Madonna, Hundred and Cameron) worked the game, which erupted into a free-for-all with 14.4 seconds remaining.

South Charleston sophomore Trevand Reese intercepted a pass from Hurricane senior quarterback Tyler Pate that was intended for junior Ben Fletcher inside the SC 20-yard line. A shoving match began immediately after Reese hit the turf, and as each team exchanged its lineup, the fracas quickly became a battle royal.

Players punched game officials and dragged them to the turf in the chaos. Both teams’ coaching staffs – as well as officers of the Charleston Police Department and UC Stadium security – worked to diffuse the situation.

The fighting lasted approximately 20 seconds. SC Coach John Messinger said it seemed to last much longer.

A total of nine South Charleston players and four Hurricane players face punitive action from the SSAC, according to Messinger.

For the Black Eagles’ on-field endeavors, that poses a greater immediate concern. With its win over the Redskins, South Charleston (11-1) will play No. 8 seed Brooke (10-2) in the semifinals at 1:30 p.m. on Saturday at UC Stadium.

The South Charleston players could each face a one-game suspension if they are retroactively ejected from the game.

“I trust Gary Ray in that he’s just like the rest of us. He understands that if there are rules and you don’t live by them, then you have anarchy,” Messinger said. “They have to make their rules in order for things to work.

“It was a tragedy that it happened to begin with. I understand that will be suspensions leveled for fighting, and different suspensions for coming onto the field.”

The names of the players awaiting the SSAC’s decision were withheld until the official announcement. Messinger said that in the case of his players facing suspension, he expects a court injunction to be filed that would allow them to play Saturday.

“We’re going to prepare as if we have a full roster, based on the fact that someone will file for an injunction,” said Messinger, who has led the Black Eagles to consecutive Class AAA state championships and has a 51-11 record in four-plus years as coach.

“I don’t know how the court system works, or the (injunction) process works, so we’re also going to prepare an alternate plan and with our backups, and we may have to use them. That’s all we can do. Our part as coaches is to get these kids prepared.”

Hurricane Coach Willis May said he had difficulty believing what he saw unfold Friday night.

“I’m sorry it had to end the way it did for them,” May said of his team, which finished the season 10-2. “If this isn’t the just the biggest shame that anyone’s ever saw, I can’t think of a worse one. I’ve never seen a game end the way this one did.”

The game ended at the 14.4-second mark. After officials, May and Messinger conferred at midfield, the coaches agreed running another play was not in the interest of anyone involved.

The officials then jogged off the field, and the respective coaches escorted their teams to their locker rooms.

The Class AA cheerleading State Tournament was delayed several months in the 2009-10 school year after parents of cheerleaders at Tolsia High School protested the results of the Region 4 tournament. Eventually, the Rebel cheerleaders were allowed to participate in the State Tournament, but then backed out.

Ray said if an injunction is filed on behalf of SC players, the Tolsia situation will not serve as a precedent in how the SSAC will handle the remainder of the playoffs.

“I haven’t even bridged that thought yet,” he said. “I’ll take it one day at a time, and I’ll have to review it in that fashion.”

The late-game fiasco was not the first time tempers threatened to boil over.

Fletcher and SC quarterback Tyler Harris were flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct after a play with approximately 6:30 remaining in the third quarter.

“Honestly, I think they just lost control,” Messinger said Friday night of the officials.

The brawl happened one week after numerous fans were ejected at a first-round Poca-Ravenswood game at RHS. Ray said there has to be more done to maintain control at high school events.

“There have been some issues that have concerned me all year, even before these things happened, and we’re going to have to work with our member schools to work on sportsmanship from fans, players and coaches’ perspective to improve,” Ray said.


Leave a Reply